The AnimeFanlistings Network Message Board

The Anime Fanlistings Network => Questions for the Senior Staff => Topic started by: ilona_ on May 10, 2006, 12:00:39 AM

Title: About the Kinomoto Touya fanlisting
Post by: ilona_ on May 10, 2006, 12:00:39 AM

The fanlisting for Kinomoto Touya (http://\"http://fanlistings.dreame.net/touya/\") was both listed in Characters: CardCaptor Sakura and Characters: Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle.

As far as I'm aware, the owner did not ask which Touya we like. I mean, the Touya in CCS and the Touya in TRC are totally different. Sure, they both are Sakura's brother. But Touya in TRC is a king, a much more mature character. So they're different.

Is this acceptable?

Title: About the Kinomoto Touya fanlisting
Post by: Jackie on May 10, 2006, 04:55:42 AM

Yes, the fanlisting is acceptable.  The characters are meant to be the same; it's a crossover by CLAMP of its various works.  You could argue that all the characters and relationships in Tsubasa are different from the original series.  However, they're meant to be the same characters as in the original series, so only one fanlisting will cover both.