The AnimeFanlistings Network Message Board

Clarifications

NAAN · 4 · 3242

Offline NAAN

  • Newbie
  • *
    • Posts: 0
    • View Profile
I just have a quick question, which might either sound redundant or stupid  :wub:  But I always like to ask just in case -- that, and I searched and searched for a possible answer to my question/s and I didn't find anything xO

Anyway, there's an approved fanlisting of a series that I like, Nurse Angel Ririka SOS (here's the fanlisting link) and it hasn't been updated...I coulda sworn that this was in the troubles section and it was taken off, but now I can't find anything like that. (And it's also not on the "Approved FLs" lists in Series) I thought of creating another fanlisting dedicated to this series since the fanlisting seemed to be dead, but now that I can't find any evidence of that, I just have 2 questions...

1) Is it all right to have two fanlistings dedicated to the same series? (It was just one season.) I would think not, since there should only be one. But since I don't know whether this one is dead or not... :D

2) This is related in part to the previous but only in a possible situation: is it all right if it has the same title (in this case, Heart Aid) as the old one? Or should it have a new one? I would have no problem with a new one, since it'd be sort of disrespectful to use the old one without permission or something :wub:


I'm also sorry if I sound like I'm rambling and you don't understand -- even I myself think this post sounds a bit unclear!  :flower:

http://revolutionmillennium.comicdish.com\'>Legendary Beings Ara & Celi // http://yoake.pure-rhythm.org\'>Yoake Umarekuru Shoujo // http://jadiner.deviantart.com\'>deviantART




Offline Mitzrael

  • TAFL Senior Staff
  • *
    • Posts: 179
  • ^ just your average ninja :D
    • View Profile
    • http://rainawhile.net
:D I dig a bit about this because I do remember troubling this series a couple of times and from the updates records, it's been removed trough 3-strike, then was approved anew and removed once again  :flower:.

Since it's no longer listed at the network, nor it's been approved since then, you are free to submit an application anytime. Also, I might clear up this right now  :wub: TAFL only accepts one fanlisting per subject (although errors might happen ^^; ) and we always try to list all our listings under their official title, along the official translation if any. In this case it should also be under the same name as the previous ones, Nurse Angel Ririka S.O.S, since that's the official name it's going by and has been released in JP, both as manga and tv series.

Finally, I see no problems naming the fanlisting as the older one, although it would sound weird and maybe even, off,  at some point  but I guess it's really up to you if approved =).

 :wub: 'hope that cleared your doubts.
« Last Edit: November 01, 2008, 12:32:39 AM by Mitzrael »
ソニア!ninja ^/_\^ | Items/Locations + Manga-ka & Directors + Music and Songs + Rivalries
Your daily dose of coffee in a pill [ rain awhile ]


Offline NAAN

  • Newbie
  • *
    • Posts: 0
    • View Profile
It sure did! Thanks for checking it up for me, and for answering my questions!  :)

http://revolutionmillennium.comicdish.com\'>Legendary Beings Ara & Celi // http://yoake.pure-rhythm.org\'>Yoake Umarekuru Shoujo // http://jadiner.deviantart.com\'>deviantART




Offline Mitzrael

  • TAFL Senior Staff
  • *
    • Posts: 179
  • ^ just your average ninja :D
    • View Profile
    • http://rainawhile.net
You're welcome anytime NAAN  :)
ソニア!ninja ^/_\^ | Items/Locations + Manga-ka & Directors + Music and Songs + Rivalries
Your daily dose of coffee in a pill [ rain awhile ]